Doc Magrogan's Oyster House - Sea Isle City, NJ

Reviews about Doc Magrogan's Oyster House - Sea Isle City, NJ

• 3 / 5

  By Matthew Smith
  Serve staff and interior décor are best. We each got different types of mixed drinks and they were mostly ice. The lobster roll was fresh, but pretty bland. Two of us had a yellow coconut rice, and it was hard and crunchy for both of us. But again, our waitress was aces, and overall it was very tasty. If we'd gotten beers and their Steamer Pots, I'm sure it would've been a different story altogether. Also, oysters are delicious, but you're gonna pay for it.
  March 02, 2017
• 5 / 5

  By Ali McQuiston
  Great place, great staff, nice octopus paintings
  January 13, 2017
• 2 / 5

  By Stephen Mooney
  Pretty big let down. Was pretty excited about this place but besides the bar, really nothing good going on. I ordered the hot pot and got mediocre seafood and extremely undercooked potatoes and corn. Like rock hard potatoes. Cracked me up when I asked the waitress for some bread to eat with the broth and she told me no, they don't do that. I explained that I would pay for the bread, she looked confused then went back to the kitchen and returned with a sliced in half hamburger bun... And charged me $2.00 for it.
  
  My advice, get a few drinks at the bar and then eat dinner at the place across the street.
  June 16, 2016